In the last few years, pumpkins in colors other than orange have become quite popular. I looked up several of my favorite seed catalogs for more information on multi colored pumpkins.
From NeSeed is Porcelain Doll. It is an exotic pink pumpkin.
The Australians seem to have cornered the market on blue
pumpkins. Blue Moon Hybrid has a mottled grey rind with
orange-yellow flesh and a flattened globe shape.
Jarrahdale Heirloom. A greenish lined pumpkin.
Silver Moon F1 pumpkin is an Australian type with dark orange flesh. This pumpkin has a pale blue color with silvery white striping and speckling.
Stokes Seed catalog has a pumpkin named Fairytale. It is similar in shape to Cinderella but has a unique tan or oak color. It looks like a wood carving.
Marina De Chioggia, below, is one of the most unique looking Italian heirloom pumpkin.
Burpee says this bright scarlet heirloom pumpkin is what the
artist who drew Cinderella's coach used as a model. Burpee introduced it to America in 1883, but it had long been popular in France. This is called Rouge Vif d' Etampe.
Johnny's Selected Seeds has a big flat pale heirloom pumpkin called Long Island Cheese.
Again, Austrailian Seed offers Queensland Blue, a dark, slate grey heavily ribbed pumpkin.
DP Seeds lists Moonscape F1 Hybrid, which they describe as a pinkish pumpkin.
It looks like there will be some more interesting decorating to
come with a bigger selection of colors of pumpkins.
And if you remember, Cinderella's pumpkin changed into a beautiful blue one until midnight.